TOWN OF CARY
DEVELOPMENT PLAN REPORT
Cary Mixed Use Site
05-SP-020
 

APPLICANT

OWNER

Cline Design Associates, PA
125 North Harrington Street
Raleigh , NC   27603

The Tetra Companies
3805 Cutshaw Avenue, Suite 501
Richmond , VA.   23230

 

TOWN OF CARY CASE MANAGER

Bob Benfield , Senior Planner

Phone:  469-4045
Email:  Bob.Benfield@TownofCary.org

Location:

Map:

The site is located south of West Chatham Street, west of South West Street , and north of Williams Street at 303 West Chatham Street .
Map

 

PROPOSED SCHEDULE OF MEETINGS

    Town Center Review Commission:

May 25, 2005

    Town Council:

June 23, 2005

 

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

Staff recommends approval of the plan.  The recommendation includes allowing a 23% reduction in the number of required parking spaces.  

The staff recommended approval of the plan, because the plan complies with Cary ’s Town Center Design Guidelines and with Cary ’s recently updated and adopted Architectural Design Guidelines.

 

 

TOWN CENTER REVIEW COMMISSION ACTION

The Town Center Review Commission unanimously recommended approval of the plan.  The recommendation included allowing a 23% reduction in the required amount of parking as recommended by the staff.  

Concerns Discussed:

  • Parking reduction:

Although up to a 50% reduction in parking may be requested, the plans proposed a 23% reduction in parking.  Staff explained that compensation for the reduction is parking was provided by utilization of the existing adjoining parking lot.  Staff also noted that in future year’s on-street parking along Chatham Street would be available and that a possible future parking deck in the central downtown area would provide additional parking opportunities for downtown businesses and the public.

  • Storm water run-off design:

Staff provided clarification at the meeting on the storm water run-off/impoundment design and explained its basic function. The Commission was encouraged to contact Cary ’s Engineering Department for a more technical overview of the proposed storm water design.

  • Open-well in southwest corner of the property:

A Commission member observed that an open well was located in the southwest corner of the property.  The applicant advised that the well would be closed and/or removed prior to any building activity on the property.

  • At two locations, the north side of the garage building is within four feet of the rear of the Carriage House and could provide an opportunity for the collection of litter and other unwanted debris.

The applicant advised that this area could possibly be used for storage and would be gated.  The gate would be of a design appropriate for the development and would prohibit the collection of litter.  

Reasons for Majority Vote:

  • The plan complies with Town Center Design Guidelines
  • The plan complies with Cary ’s Architectural Design Standards
  • Although a parking reduction was requested, other off-site parking arrangements were included in the plan (shared parking with the adjoining western parking lot)
  • The plan’s overall appeal and contribution to the vitality of the downtown area.

 

 

 

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

 

The plans propose a four-story predominately brick building containing 9,549 square feet of commercial development on the first floor and 24 dwelling units on the second, third, and fourth floors.  A three-story secondary building containing six dwelling units would be located south of the primary commercial/ residential building.  The maximum density allowed is 50 units per acre, and the proposed density is 30 units per acre.  At-grade parking is proposed behind the commercial/residential building within the first floor area of the secondary residential building and within one-story garages facing Williams Street .  

Considering the unique nature of the downtown area, certain development requirements are not applicable within the Town Center district, such as:

·         The required number of parking spaces may be reduced up to 50 percent, provided there is adequate on-street parking available.  The plans propose 48 parking spaces; however, 62 parking spaces are required, resulting in a proposed 23% reduction in the number of required parking spaces.  Parking would also be available in the adjoining western parking lot, which is not fully utilized daily.

 

·         The streetscape and buffer widths normally required are not applicable in the Town Center District. Street tree plantings and screening from adjoining properties, however, must be consistent with Downtown Design Guidelines.  This plan would comply with these provisions.

 

The plans will comply with all applicable Town Center Design Guidelines, which provide:

·         That buildings be located close to the street right-of-way and sidewalk, with parking located behind the buildings;

·         That architectural form, facades, materials, and colors complement adjoining properties and eliminate blank walls;

·         That parking be placed to the side or rear of buildings;

·         That on-street parking be encouraged; and

·         That required landscaping consists of streetscape, of appropriate screening from adjoining properties, of screened parking areas, of foundation plantings, and of accent plantings.  

During the review and approval of the ballroom addition to the Mathew’s House, which is located west of the proposed Cary Mixed Use site, staff and the Town Center Review Commission (TCRC) recommended the brick wall north and east of the Mathew’s House be extended west along Chatham Street across the frontage of the parking lot.  The extension of the brick wall would screen the parking lot from off-site views, as required by the Downtown Design Guidelines.  The staff and the TCRC concluded that a wall would provide the desired level of parking area screening and would provide a suitable transition from the Mathew’s House to the Cary Mixed Use site.  The Town Council deferred action on the brick wall extension until submittal of the third phase of development, the Cary Mixed Use site.  

The plans propose to screen the adjoining western parking lot from Chatham Street by utilizing a 4’ high picket fence located between 2’ X 2’ X 7’ high brick columns at set intervals.  The columns would match the columns surrounding the Mathews House.  Ornamental plantings and benches would be installed along the Chatham Street side of the fence and a double offset row of evergreen shrubs would be located adjacent to the parking area.  The combination of fence, brick columns and evergreen plantings should adequately screen the parking area from off-site views.

 

   

PARCEL INFORMATION

Parcel #

Realid #

Area

0764314213

0068968

0.987 acres

 

ZONING AND LAND USE PLAN COMPLIANCE

 

Current Zoning:  Town Center

Sub District:  High Intensity Mixed Use (HMXD)

Town Limits:  The property is inside Cary ’s town limits.

Land Use Compliance:  The Land Use Plan allows for high density mixed use development.  A mixture of commercial, office, and residential is allowed.

 

 

LOCAL WAKE COUNTY SCHOOL ESTIMATES AND CAPACITY IMPACTS

Current 20th Day Enrollment at the schools for which this parcel is currently zoned:

Building Capacity

Percent occupied

Projected Number of Students

Cary Elementary

606

517

117%

5

Reedy Creek Middle

850

737

87%

3

Cary High

2,410

2,446

99%

4

Total for all Zoned Schools

3,866

3,700

 

12

 

Current Enrollment and Permanent Seat Capacity are based on data for the school year 2004-2005, as supplied by the Wake County Public School System.  Actual school assignment will be determined at the time of development.

 

LANDSCAPE

 

The plan would be required to comply with all landscape requirements.  The plans provide street trees, foundation plantings, shade trees within the parking area, screening of the parking area behind the retail/residential building, and landscape screening from adjoining properties.

 

 

BUILDING ELEVATION

 

Building Height:  55’ (maximum height)

Building Size:  Approximately 38,000 square feet (9,549 sq. ft. of retail space on the first floor, 24 dwelling units on the second, third and fourth floors)

Building Materials and Colors:  Red-brown brick; cream stucco; cream, tan and blue-green hardi siding; white hardi trim; clear anodized aluminum storefront; charcoal cloth awnings and canopies; black asphalt shingles; and galvalume standing seam metal.

 

 

TRAFFIC

 

The development of 9,500 square feet of retail development combined with 30 dwelling units would not require a traffic impact study, because the development would not generate more that 100 peak hour trips as defined by the Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance.

 

Staff Contact:  Dick Moore, 462-3937, Email:  dick.moore@townofcary.org

 

ROADWAY DESIGN

 

The Town’s Comprehensive Transportation Plan requires an ultimate 43’ back-to-back cross section for this segment of West Chatham Street .  The 43’ dimension consists of one lane in each direction with parallel parking on each side.  Sufficient pavement currently exists and road widening, therefore, is not required as a part of this development plan. 

 

Staff Contact:  Tammy Spivey, 462-3933, Email:  tammy.spivey@townofcary.org

 

UTILITIES

 

This development has access to Cary water and sewer services and would be required to comply with Town utility policies and standards.

 

Staff Contact:  Shuyan Tian, 469-4381, Email:  shuyan.tian@townofcary.org

 

STORM WATER

 

The project will be required to comply with all Town of Cary storm water requirements.

 

Staff Contact:  Tom Horstman, 469-4347, Email:  tom.horstman@townofcary.org

 

PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION AND CONCERNS

 

Adjoining property owners were notified during staff's initial review of this plan.  Staff has received no inquiries objecting to the request regarding this proposed development.