The Town of Cary Land Use Plan
6.0 PLAN CONCEPTS AND LAND USE DEFINITIONS
This chapter explains and defines each of the land use designations, or categories, used on the Land Use Plan Map, and provides criteria that describe the vision, characteristics, and criteria for each land use category. The emphasis in this chapter is on defining the form, function and allowed uses and mixing of uses for each land use category, as well as providing general criteria for locating and siting these land use elements or their components. The Town recognizes that some of the criteria given in this chapter may not be applicable or practicable in all cases. In addition, the Town welcomes creative development that differs from the criteria outlined in this chapter, if the general spirit and intent of the criteria are met.
In order to fully grasp the vision for each of the Plans land use categories, one must also be aware of the design vision that should guide the built form for each of the land use categories, which is a central feature of this Plan. The design vision for development in Cary is discussed in Chapter 7.
The land uses fall into six major categories:
Outline of the Chapter:
The first section of the chapter explains the urban model upon which the Plan is based, so that one understands the rationale for each of the land use elements described in the subsequent sections, especially the concept of activity centers. Each of the next six sections describe the land uses for one of the six major land use categories (given in the list above). The final section describes a Plan element called a Major Employment Center, which is a conceptual element not specifically designated on the Plan Map.
6.1 The Urban Model: Neighborhoods, Communities, and Regions
The Land Use Plan for Cary is based on an urban model in which small pieces, or neighborhoods, fit together to form medium-sized pieces, or communities, and adjoining communities are fitted together to form regions. These pieces of the Plan -- neighborhoods, communities, and regions -- are defined below:
The Neighborhood:
Neighborhoods are contiguous areas, usually containing approximately 600 to 1,500 dwellings, or about 1,500 to 3,500 people.25 Neighborhoods consist not only of homes, but also the parks, streets, shops, schools, and other land uses that occur within their boundaries. The size of a neighborhood is not set arbitrarily at 600 - 1,500 homes. Rather, it is based on the observation that a population of this size is needed to support so-called "first tier" public and private facilities, such as grocery stores, drug stores, service stations, neighborhood parks, daycare centers, places of worship, and in some cases, elementary schools.
Generally, neighborhood boundaries are defined by roadway arterials surrounding the neighborhood, or by a combination of arterials and through secondary26 roads. In some cases, boundaries may also be defined by geographic or topographic features, such as streams, gullies, or hills. Ideally, neighborhoods are designed so that no home is more than approximately one-half mile from the center of the neighborhood. The neighborhood concept is illustrated in Figure 6.1.
The Community:
The next larger piece used in our model of Cary is the community. A community is a collection of approximately 3-5 adjacent neighborhoods, with a total population of about 10,000 to 20,000 people, or about 2,000 to 7,000 dwellings. This population range for a community is based on analysis that demonstrates that a population of approximately 10,000 to 20,000 is needed to support "second tier" public and private facilities -- facilities that are required less often than on a daily basis. "Second-tier" facilities include very large supermarkets, specialty stores, large discount stores (e.g., K-Mart), community parks, large-sized places of worship, and often, middle schools. Communities are also large enough to support specialty medical offices, legal firms, mid-sized employers, community libraries, and fire stations. Confirming the population range for a community, the market in Cary tends to establish community-sized shopping centers and facilities to serve exactly this range of population and housing.27 The community concept is illustrated in Figure 6.1.
The Region:
The largest piece used in our model is the region. A region is made up of a collection of adjacent communities, providing a total population of approximately 80,000 to 150,000 people. The region concept is very useful for planning purposes, but can be difficult to apply in the Triangle area with clarity because, in several instances, regions overlap municipal boundaries. Regions include the population needed to support "third tier" public and private facilities, which include regional shopping malls, very large employers, large home-supply and building stores, high schools, certain private schools, community colleges, large civic recreation centers, regional parks, and hospitals. The region concept is illustrated in Figure 6.1.
6.2 Activity Centers
Activity Centers are the most critical elements of the Land Use Plan. The concept and definition of activity centers is based on the urban model concept of neighborhoods, communities, and regions, as described in the preceding subsection.
Neighborhoods, communities and regions are each centered or organized around focus areas, which contain the shopping, services, recreation, and office and institutional facilities needed to support the neighborhood, community, or region, respectively. These focus areas are surrounded by support areas, which include the highest-density housing within the neighborhood, community, or region, with housing densities progressively decreasing outward from the focus areas. Focus areas, with their surrounding support areas, are called activity centers. (See Figure 6.2) There are therefore three different types of activity centers -- neighborhood activity centers, community activity centers, and regional activity centers.
These three different types of activity centers are similar in spatial arrangement and function, but vary in terms of their scale and intensity. Regional activity centers are larger and more intense than community activity centers, and community activity centers are larger and more intense than neighborhood activity centers. Essentially, activity centers are "compact village centers" which can occur in three different sizes -- small (neighborhood), medium (community), or large (regional).
Activity centers are physically and aesthetically unified areas, where all elements and land uses are designed to function as an integrated whole (rather than as a series of unconnected, unrelated developments). The diverse facilities of the focus area are located in close proximity to one another, so that all essential facilities for the community are concentrated in one convenient location. Housing in the support area needs to be physically linked with the focus area in order to facilitate pedestrian movement between the two areas. (See Figure 6.3)
It is not anticipated or expected that an entire activity center will be built as a single development, under a single owner or developer, or that all the components of an activity center will be built at the same time. The intent is that the uses and characteristics that typify activity centers (as described in this chapter) will be embodied by each component of the activity center as it is built, so that ultimately all of the diverse components will work and function as an integrated and complete activity center.
Activity centers include both the focus area (the commercial, institutional, and office core) and the surrounding support area (with high and medium-density residential). The support area is critical because it provides the concentrated population necessary to support both the focus area and possible future transit stops, and it serves as a buffer between the more intense uses of the focus area and the lower-density residential uses of the surrounding neighborhood.
Furthermore, support areas provide context and community for higher density housing. Under the conventional suburban development model, higher-density uses, such as apartments, condominiums, and townhouses have been located in large self-contained developments having little physical connection to the surrounding community. Residents of these developments have often been unable to walk to shops and businesses, and must rely on automotive means to make daily necessity trips. Thus, life in such developments has often conferred on their residents the disadvantages of high-density living without any of the advantages possible under a different high-density model. The advantages offered by the activity center and support area model are the pedestrian-oriented nature of the activity center, the sense of community offered by a highly connected street layout, and the convenient proximity to shopping, services, daycare, and parks. Finally, this model minimizes automotive trips on arterial streets, thereby reducing traffic and congestion and saving the Town road expense.
A more intense activity center can fulfill the functions of a less intense activity center as well. That is, a community activity center, in addition to functioning as a community activity center, may also function as the neighborhood activity center for the adjacent neighborhood. Similarly, a regional activity center may function as a community activity center for the surrounding community, and/or as a neighborhood activity center for the surrounding neighborhood. And, a neighborhood, community, or regional activity center can serve as the focus area for an office/industrial park.
This does not mean that it is possible that every neighborhood could have either a regional or community activity center in place of a neighborhood activity center. Community activity centers have much larger service populations than neighborhood activity centers, and the town will, by definition, have fewer community activity centers than neighborhood activity centers. Similarly, regional activity centers have much larger service populations than community activity centers, and the town will, therefore, have fewer regional activity centers than community activity centers.
There may be cases in which two small neighborhoods are served by a single neighborhood activity center. For example, if the housing densities and numbers of dwellings in two adjoining neighborhoods are very low, the market might not exist for separate neighborhood centers for each neighborhood. However the two neighborhoods taken together might support one center.
The purpose and function of each of type of activity center is summarized below:
Neighborhood Activity Centers (NAC):
The focus area portion of a neighborhood activity center contains facilities vital to the day-to-day activity of the neighborhood. Thus, the central focus area might contain a grocery store, drug store, service station, church or synagogue, daycare, limited office space, and small park. These diverse facilities are ideally located in close proximity to one another in the focus area, so that all the essential facilities for the neighborhood are located in one convenient location, accessible in a single stop.
The support area part of a the neighborhood activity center, which surrounds the activity centers focus area, contains the neighborhoods highest-density housing. This design enables the highest concentration of population within the neighborhood to access the focus area via a short walk, thus reducing the number of automotive trips for daily shopping needs. This arrangement also provides a concentration of population sufficient to support future transit services, with a single transit stop serving the shops and services in the focus area and adjacent higher-density housing in the support area.
Ideally, neighborhood activity centers are located at the center of a neighborhood. However, in many cases it is difficult to achieve this central placement. In such cases, the neighborhood model takes on a slightly different arrangement, with the activity center moved to the periphery of, but still within, the neighborhood. This arrangement has a disadvantage, since half of the residents within the neighborhood must make longer trips to reach the activity center. However, moving the activity center to the periphery also provides advantages, as pass-by activity center traffic (visitors/customers to the activity center that do not live in the neighborhood) does not have to enter the neighborhood and merchants may be placed closer to arterial traffic.
Community Activity Centers (CAC):
The focus area portion of a community activity center contains the shopping, services, recreation, employment, and institutional facilities that are required and supported by the surrounding community (using our definition of a community). Thus, a community focus area could contain a large supermarket, large drug store, large chain retail/discount store (e.g., Wal-Mart, K-Mart, Best Buy, etc.), specialty shops, service stations, one or more large places of worship, a community park, mid-size offices and employers, and perhaps an elementary or middle school. A community focus area may also serve as the neighborhood focus area for the neighborhood(s) immediately adjacent to the community focus area. The community focus area is therefore considerably larger and more diverse in its land uses than is a neighborhood focus area.
As with neighborhood activity centers, the focus area of a community activity center is surrounded by the activity centers support area, containing the communitys highest-density housing, with housing densities declining outward from the focus area. Housing densities in the support area tend to be higher than those in a neighborhood activity centers support area.
Regional Activity Centers (RAC):
For a regional activity center, its focus area contains the shopping, services, recreation, employment, and institutional facilities supported by and serving an entire region. Thus, a regional focus area could include a regional shopping mall, a number of major employers, restaurant and entertainment facilities, and a large high school or community college. A regional focus area may also serve as the neighborhood or community focus area for the neighborhood(s) or community(s) immediately adjacent to the regional focus area. The regional focus area is therefore considerably larger and more diverse in its land uses than is a community focus area.
As with neighborhood and community activity centers, the focus area for a regional activity center is surrounded by the activity centers support area, containing the regions highest-density housing, with housing densities declining outward from the focus area. Housing densities in the support area tend to be higher than those in neighborhood and community activity centers support areas. A regional activity centers support area is larger and more dense than a community activity centers support area.
6.2.1 General Criteria for All Activity Centers
This subsection describes criteria and characteristics which are common to all three types of activity centers.
Type and Mix of Land Uses:
Transit Access:
6.2.2 Criteria Specific to Neighborhood Activity Centers
Type and Mix of Land Uses:
Commercial:
|
Institutional:
|
Office:
|
Residential:
|
- uses considered noxious when located next to a residential neighborhood
- large retailers, discount stores
- warehousing, manufacturing, and other industrial uses
- large employers
- establishments that do not [primarily] serve the surrounding neighborhood
Locational Criteria:
Neighborhood activity centers are located and arranged according to the following guidelines:
| Population Served: | 1,500 to 5,000 |
| Service Radius: | 0.5 to 1 miles |
| Minimum Separation from other Neighborhood Activity Centers:28 | 0.75 to 1 miles |
| Minimum Separation from Community or Regional Activity Centers: | 1 - 1.5 miles |
| Maximum distance that nonresidential uses may radiate outwards from the center of the activity center (along roadways):29 | approximately 600-700 ft. (about 1/8 mi.) |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that high-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/8 mi., apprx. |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that medium-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/4 mi. |
Site Area and Development Size and Intensity:
The size of a neighborhood activity center, and the allocation of land area and building space between different uses in the activity center, should fall around these ranges:
| Average Area | |
| Combined focus and support areas | 28 to 70 acres30 |
| Support Area | 20 to 40 acres31 |
| Focus Area, Acreage | |
| focus area total acreage | 8.5 to 30 acres32 |
| focus area, commercial portion | 5 to 10 acres |
| focus area, office portion | 2.5 to 10 acres33 |
| focus area, institutional portion | 1 to 10 acres34 |
| focus area, public space (park, plaza) | 0.10 to 0.25 acre35 |
| Focus Area, Floor Space | |
| total retail floor space, acceptable range | 50,000 to 100,000 sq. ft. |
| total office floor space, acceptable range | 25,000 to 100,000 sq. ft. |
| total institutional floor space, acceptable range | 2,500 to 25,000 sq. ft.36 |
| max. size of largest non-grocery retailer | 10,000 to 30,000 sq. ft. |
| max. size of grocery/supermarket | 50,000 to 60,000 sq. ft. |
The data in the table above are based not only on current development literature, but also on the actual observed characteristics of existing shopping centers in Cary. This is also true for the corresponding tables for community and regional activity centers, in Sections 6.2.3 and 6.2.4. A listing of the total acreage, square footage, and other characteristics of each of Carys existing shopping centers is given in Appendix B.
Location of Focus and Support Areas about the Quadrants of an Intersection:
Neighborhood activity centers are generally sited on the Growth Plan Map in one of three types of locations:
The manner in which a neighborhood activity centers focus and support areas should be arranged about an intersection or roadway, for each of the above three types of locations, are as follows:
Guidelines for Locating other Uses, Aside from the Focus and Support Areas, about the [Remaining] Quadrants of the Intersection:
A) Other Commercial Uses:
The bulk of a neighborhood activity centers commercial land uses, including the neighborhood shopping center, should be located in the focus area. However, a limited amount of commercial space may also be located outside of the focus area, on one of the other quadrants of the intersection or sides of the arterial, subject to the following guidelines:
B) Other Office and Institutional Uses:
While a significant portion of a neighborhood activity centers office and institutional land uses should be located in the focus area, some office and institutional space may also be located outside of the focus area, on the other quadrants of the intersection or sides of the arterial. For example, a quadrant outside the focus area might contain a school or place of worship (although at least one place of worship would be best placed in the focus area, capitalizing on opportunities for shared parking areas), or a small office building. Office uses on quadrants outside of the focus area should generally not cause the total office acreage and floorspace for the activity center as a whole to exceed the office acreage and floorspace ranges given for the focus area, under Site Area and Development Size and Intensity, above.
C) Other Residential Uses:
Lower-density residential uses may also be placed on one or two of the quadrants outside of the focus area, preferably buffered by a berm or wall from intersection noise and views. In general, this should only be done if sufficient amounts of high- and medium-density housing have already been provided for in other quadrants of the activity center.
Other Siting Considerations:
6.2.3 Criteria Specific to Community Activity Centers
Type and Mix of Land Uses:
Commercial:
|
Institutional:
|
Office:
|
Residential:
|
- any uses which would be considered noxious when located next to a residential neighborhood
- warehousing, manufacturing, and other industrial uses
Locational Criteria:
Community activity centers are located and arranged according to the following guidelines:
| Population Served | 10,000 to 20,000 |
| Service Radius: | 1 to 2 miles |
| Minimum Separation from other Community Activity Centers: | 2 to 3 miles |
| Minimum Separation from Neighborhood Activity Centers: | 1 to 1.5 miles |
| Minimum Separation from Regional Activity Centers: | 2 to 3 miles |
| Maximum distance that nonresidential uses may radiate outwards from the center of the activity center (along roadways)40: | approximately 1000 ft. (about 1/5 mi.) |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that high-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/8 mi., apprx. |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that medium-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/4 mi. |
Site Area and Development Size and Intensity:
| Average Area | |
| Combined focus and support areas | 67 to 145 acres41 |
| Support Area | 40 to 80 acres42 |
| Focus Area, Acreage | |
| total focus area acreage | 27.5 to 65 acres43 |
| focus area, commercial portion | 15 to 25 acres |
| focus area, office portion | 10 to 20 acres44 |
| focus area, institutional portion | 2.5 to 20 acres45 |
| focus area, public space (park, plaza) | 0.2 to 0.5 acre46 |
| Focus Area, Floor Space | |
| total retail floor space | 150,000 to 250,000 sq. ft. |
| total office floor Space | 100,000 to 300,000 sq. ft. |
| total institutional floor Space | 5,000 to 100,000+ sq. ft.47 |
| max. size of largest non-grocery retailer | 50,000 to 100,000 sq. ft. |
| max. size of grocery/supermarket | 80,000 sq. ft. |
Location of Focus and Support Areas about the Quadrants of an Intersection:
Community activity centers are generally sited on the Growth Plan Map in one of three types of locations:
The manner in which a community activity centers focus and support areas should be arranged about an intersection or roadway, for each of the above three types of locations, are as follows:
Guidelines for Locating other Uses, Aside from the Focus and Support Areas, about the [Remaining] Quadrants of the Intersection:
A) Other Office and Institutional Uses:
While a significant portion of a community activity centers office and institutional land uses should be located in the focus area, some office and institutional space may also be located outside of the focus area, on the other quadrants of the intersection or sides of the arterial. For example, a quadrant outside the focus area might contain a school or place of worship (although at least one place of worship would be best placed in the focus area, capitalizing on opportunities for shared parking areas), or an office building. Office uses on quadrants outside of the focus area should generally not cause the total office acreage and floorspace for the activity center as a whole to exceed the office acreage and floorspace ranges given for the focus area, under Site Area and Development Size and Intensity, above.
B) Other Residential Uses:
Lower-density residential uses may also be placed on one or two of the quadrants outside of the focus area, preferably buffered by a berm or wall from intersection noise and views. In general, this should only be done if sufficient amounts of high- and medium-density housing have already been provided for in other quadrants of the activity center.
Other Siting Considerations:
6.2.4 Criteria Specific to Regional Activity Centers
Type and Mix of Land Uses:
Commercial:
|
Institutional:
|
Office:
|
Residential:
|
- any uses which would be considered noxious when located next to high or medium-density residential areas
- warehousing, manufacturing, and other industrial uses
Locational Criteria:
Regional activity centers are located and arranged according to the following guidelines:
| Population Served: | 80,000 to 200,000 |
| Service Radius: | 3 to 6 miles or 15 to 30 minute drive, maximum |
| Minimum Separation from other Regional Activity Centers: | 5 to 6 miles |
| Minimum Separation from Neighborhood Activity Centers: | 1 to 1.5 miles |
| Minimum Separation from Community Activity Centers: | 2 to 3 miles |
| Maximum distance that nonresidential uses may radiate outwards from the center of the activity center (along roadways)49: | approximately 1300-1500 ft. (about 1/4 mi.) |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that high-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/4 mi. |
| Maximum distance away from edge of Focus Area that medium-density housing (a part of the Support Area) should be located: | 1/4 - 1/2 mi. |
Site Area and Development Size and Intensity:
The size of a regional activity center, and the allocation of land area and building space between different uses in the activity center, should fall around these ranges:
| Average Area | |
| Combined focus and support areas | 200 to 500 acres |
| Support Area | 100 to 200 acres |
| Focus Area, Acreage | |
| total focus area acreage | 100 to 300 acres |
| focus area, commercial portion | 75 to 150 acres |
| focus area, office portion | 50 to 100 acres50 |
| focus area, institutional portion | 2.5 to 20 acres51 |
| focus area, residential portion | 50 to 100 acres52 |
| focus area, public space (parks, plazas) | 5 to 15 acres |
| Focus Area, Floor Space | |
| total retail floor space | 750,000 to 1,500,000 sq. ft. |
| total office floor space | 500,000 to 2,000,000 sq. ft. |
| total institutional floor space | 10,000 to 100,000+ sq. ft.53 |
Location of Focus and Support Areas about the Quadrants of an Intersection:
Regional activity centers are generally sited on the Growth Plan Map at the intersection of two arterial roadways, or at a freeway interchange with an arterial. The focus area should not occupy more than three quadrants of the intersection. As much of the support area as possible should be located on the same quadrant(s) with focus area elements, so that only a minimal number of support area residents will need to cross an arterial or freeway to reach part of the focus area. However, portions of the support area may also occupy one or more of the other quadrants of the intersection. (See Fig. 6.8)
Guidelines for Locating other Uses, Aside from the Focus and Support Areas, about the [Remaining] Quadrants of the Intersection:
A) Other Office and Institutional Uses:
While a significant portion of a regional activity centers office and institutional land uses should be located in the focus area, some office and institutional space may also be located outside of the focus area, on the other quadrants of the intersection. For example, a quadrant outside the focus area might contain a school or place of worship (although at least one place of worship would be best placed in the focus area, capitalizing on opportunities for shared parking areas), or an office building. Office uses on quadrants outside of the focus area should generally not cause the total office acreage and floorspace for the activity center as a whole to exceed the office acreage and floorspace ranges given for the focus area, under Site Area and Development Size and Intensity, above.
Other Siting Considerations:
6.3 Office Parks and Office/Industrial Parks
While neighborhood, community, and regional activity centers can accommodate substantial amounts of employment, they cannot and should not accommodate sites for all types of employment. The primary focus of neighborhood and community activity centers is to provide goods, services, and facilities in support of their surrounding neighborhood and community, respectively. Thus, the types of employment offered in these two types of activity centers are largely commercial and office, and the total amount of office space available in these two types of activity centers may not be sufficient for larger firms. Although regional activity centers are quite large, and may offer substantial amounts of office space, there often are not enough of them to accommodate all of a towns employment needs. For example, only one additional regional activity center is envisioned for Cary in the Growth Plan, in addition to Carys two existing regional focus areas -- the Cary Towne Center Mall area and the Crossroads Plaza area. It is unlikely that the addition of one or even two regional activity centers will be sufficient to accommodate Carys employment growth over the next twenty years.
Neighborhood, community, and regional activity centers are also not intended to provide industrial space. Industrial uses tend to require larger amounts of land, and tend to defeat the small-town, compact, pedestrian orientation envisioned for neighborhood, community, and regional activity centers. Industrial uses are also often incompatible with the residential, office, and commercial uses within a neighborhood, community, or regional activity center. Thus, this Plan includes the land use categories of Office Parks and Office/Industrial Parks to accommodate additional office and industrial growth, outside of activity centers.
Office Parks and Office/Industrial Parks are planned concentrations of office and industrial development, having interconnected internal road networks and shared open spaces. The individual buildings are sited so that they relate well to one another, and are of compatible design and materials. Office & Industrial Parks can contain either office or industrial uses, or both, while Office Parks are primarily for office uses. Aside from that distinction, Office & Industrial Parks and Office Parks are very similar in form and characteristics. Examples of Office & Industrial Parks include Kitty Hawk Executive Park near RDU and the Weston PUD, while examples of Office Parks include the SAS campus and Regency Park. Typical industrial uses for Office & Industrial Parks include warehousing, mini-storage, trans-shipment facilities, building trades offices and facilities, and light manufacturing and assembling. Typical office uses for both types of centers include large- and mid-sized corporate offices, as well as office space for smaller firms, office condominiums, and so forth.
Large office/office&industrial parks may also contain a limited amount of commercial space, concentrated into a central focus area. These commercial uses supply goods and services required by the firms located in the office/office&industrial park, such as office supplies, reproduction services, and dining establishments. If an office/office&industrial park is sited next to a neighborhood or community activity center, then that activity center may also serve as the focus area for the office/office&industrial park.
Institutional uses may also be provided in [the focus area of] an office/office&industrial park, but should be limited to those institutional uses that would not better serve the community by being located in either a neighborhood, community, or regional activity center.
6.3.1 Office & Industrial Park and Office Park Criteria
| Note: The notation "Office/Industrial Park" in this subsection means "either an Office Park or an Office & Industrial Park." |
Type and Mix of Land Uses
Commercial:
|
Institutional:
|
- most institutional uses (see above comments)
- heavy industry, smokestack industry
- industries generating appreciable amounts of pollution, or any amounts that would be noxious to nearby residential areas
- forestry and agriculture
- supermarkets
- large discount stores and other large retailers
- establishments which dont directly serve the business and employee needs of the office/industrial park.
Site Area and Development Size
| Average Area | |
| Typical total acreage, office/industrial park | 50 to 750 acres54 |
| Focus Area | less than 10 acres |
| Max. commercial floorspace in focus area | 100,000 sq. ft. |
Locational Criteria and Service Area
Office/Industrial Park Site Layout
Other Siting Considerations:
Transit Access:
6.4 Nonresidential Uses Not in Activity Centers or Office/Industrial Parks: Commercial, Office/Institutional, and Office/Industrial
This Plan envisions that most nonresidential uses will be located in neighborhood, community, or regional activity centers, or office & industrial parks, or office parks. However, not all nonresidential uses are appropriate for activity centers or office/industrial parks. For example, a veterinary clinic, although a commercial use, may not be appropriate for an activity center, due to levels of animal noise and perhaps the outdoor space needed for kennel runs. Also, not all arterial intersections are designated to have activity centers, and residential uses may not be viable on all quadrants of such intersections.
This Plan addresses these problems in three ways. First, this subsection defines three nonresidential land use categories in order to designate additional nonresidential areas on the Growth Plan Map, outside of activity centers. These categories are used to designate appropriate uses for the sizable number of small undeveloped "infill areas" in Cary (pockets of undeveloped land surrounded by developed land) that are appropriate for nonresidential development, and for the undeveloped portions of some partially-built activity centers.
Second, this Plan acknowledges that it is nearly impossible to pre-select appropriate sites on the Growth Plan Map for the full range of the mostly small-scale nonresidential uses (especially commercial ones) that dont logically belong in activity centers. Rather than attempt to map sites for all such uses, this Plan recommends that such uses simply be sited in accord with the general spirit and intent of the Plan, subject to the design guidelines of Chapter 7.
Third, this subsection provides for limited nonresidential uses at arterial intersections that are not designated as activity centers. (The specific provisions are given below in 6.4.1.)
The three nonresidential use categories, outside of activity centers, are defined as follows:
6.4.1 Criteria for Nonresidential Uses Not in Activity Centers or Office/Industrial Parks
Type and Mix of Land Uses
- Any uses considered noxious when located next to the adjacent or nearby properties and land uses
- Any uses generating appreciable amounts of pollution
- "neighborhood" types of institutional uses such as neighborhood-sized libraries, parks, places of worship, and primary schools, which ideally should be located in activity centers
Other Locational Considerations
- Residential uses are unviable on the quadrant(s) to be converted to nonresidential uses, due to traffic, noise, pollution, or other impacts from the intersection.
- No more than a few acres should generally be used for nonresidential purposes on each of the intersection quadrants, unless otherwise indicated on the Growth Plan Map.
- Commercial uses are not recommended for more than one quadrant of the intersection.
- The commercial uses should not be comparable in scale with an activity center of any size.
6.5 Residential Town-Planning Elements
Neighborhoods, including activity center focus and support areas, contain the towns housing. Residential areas come in many different densities and configurations, so it is necessary to have town plan-making "pieces" (land use categories) that represent different types of residential areas. Thus, this Plan uses five types of residential pieces, or categories, to construct neighborhoods and the residential portions of activity centers. These categories are: very low density residential, low-density residential, medium-density residential, high-density residential, and Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND).
This section first provides a basic overview of the definitions of these five types of residential categories. Criteria common to all these residential categories -- and to neighborhoods in general -- are then presented. Next, criteria which are specific to traditional neighborhood are discussed. Finally, the definition and criteria for an optional type of residential development -- "clustered low-density residential development" -- are presented.
6.5.1 Overview of the Residential Categories
Very Low Density Residential:
Very low density residential refers to densities of less than 1 dwelling per acre, with uses typically restricted to single family detached units. Lot sizes typically range between 1 and 5 or more acres and the development typically relies on wells and private septic systems. Most areas designated as very low density are therefore beyond Carys ultimate urban services boundary.55 Very low density residential areas designated on the Growth Plan Map that are within the Jordan Lake Water Supply Watersheds 1-mile Critical Area have a minimum lot size of about 2 acres.
Low-Density Residential:
Low-density residential ranges from 1 to 3 dwelling units per acre, with uses restricted to single family detached units. Lot sizes typically range from approximately 12,000 sq. ft. to 1 acre. Smaller lot sizes are possible using clustered development, although the overall density should not exceed 3 dwellings per acre. (The cluster development option is explained in Subsection 6.5.4, below.)
Medium-Density Residential:
Medium-density residential development includes housing densities between 3 and 8 dwellings per acre. It can include a mixture of residential uses including single family detached uses, semi-detached units, single family attached units, duplexes and triplexes, townhouses, and low rise apartments.
High-Density Residential:
High-density residential contains housing at densities of anywhere from 8 to 30 units per acre, depending on where the high-density dwellings are located (see Subsection 6.5.2). Typical uses include townhouses, condominiums, apartments, and possibly duplexes or triplexes. In some cases, higher housing densities may be necessary to support future regional rail transit stops, high-volume bus transit stops, or to support regional activity centers or major employment centers.
Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND):
(A) Definition:
Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND) refers to the traditional American neighborhood patterns that typified the pre-World War II era, which were characterized by a highly-connected street pattern, often based on a grid. Traditional neighborhood development refers principally to a particular development style and design, and is not necessarily indicative of a particular residential density -- although in general traditional neighborhood developments have higher gross densities than do conventional low density residential developments. (Chapter 7 describes the design features of traditional neighborhood development in more detail.)
In a traditional neighborhood development, streets tend to be somewhat narrower and emphasize a pedestrian orientation and scale. Streets are lined with street trees and sidewalks on both sides of the street. Diverse housing types and lot sizes are intermixed throughout the neighborhood. Houses are located close to their fronting street, often with porches looking out at the street. Single-family lots tend to have narrow frontages, allowing housing densities to increase to medium-density levels, while still maintaining single-family character. More use is made of ancillary buildings such as "in-law apartments" over garages. There may also be some degree of nonresidential uses mixed in among the residential uses in the neighborhood, such as a home-based doctors or law offices.
Public spaces, such as formal neighborhood parks, squares, or village greens are essential features, serving as focal points for community interaction and compensating for smaller lot sizes. Some types of traditional neighborhoods emphasize the use of alleys to provide parking areas and access for household public services. Most traditional neighborhoods emphasize the use of on-street parallel parking throughout the neighborhood, which helps to reduce traffic speeds, buffer sidewalk pedestrians from traffic, and to supply daily, overflow, or guest parking.
In the ideal model, traditional neighborhoods have what is effectively a neighborhood activity center at the center of the neighborhood, where day-to-day grocery and convenience shopping, an elementary school, places of worship, a town green, and the higher-density housing are located. For purposes of differentiating this type of activity center, we call it a traditional neighborhood activity center. In some cases, the traditional neighborhood activity center may be located at the edge of the neighborhood, with direct access to an arterial or through secondary street.
(B) The Motivation for Using Traditional Neighborhood Development in Cary:
The residential development market trend over the past decade has been towards ever-decreasing single-family lot sizes. Cary has not escaped this trend. Unfortunately, small-lot single family developments are frequently built using the same design features that typify large-lot single family developments, often without success. Small-lot development has a significantly different feel and sense of place than large-lot development, and should not always be "shoe-horned" into the conventional large-lot design model.
Traditional neighborhood development offers a much improved model for creating small-lot neighborhoods, where small lots are turned to the advantage of the neighborhood, helping to create vibrant streets with a strong sense of place. Rather than ignore the market trend towards smaller lots, this Plan therefore encourages and recommends that small-lot residential development be built using traditional neighborhood development designs. (Small-lot residential development is defined here as lot sizes that fall below the guidelines for Low Density Residential; see Subsection 6.5.2)
(C) Recommendations for Use of Traditional Neighborhood Development:
Traditional neighborhood development is available as an option in all areas marked as Low Density Residential on the Growth Plan Map. The fact that traditional neighborhood development can be used as an option in all areas marked as Low Density Residential does not imply a specific change in residential density, although in general TND densities are somewhat higher than conventional low density residential developments. The table in Subsection 6.5.2, below, shows the wide range of densities that may be possible in TNDs, depending on the specific location and context for the particular traditional neighborhood development. The specific maximum TND density that would be appropriate in a given area will depend on the transportation, environmental, and infrastructure impacts that would be expected.
There are distinct areas in the Growth Plan Study Area that are more suitable for traditional neighborhood development than are others. Figure 6.9 shows the areas most suitable for TND uses, due to proximity to major arterials and the potential for establishing an arterial grid around those areas. These areas will most likely be able to support the widest range of TND densities.
In particular, for the area east of the Very Low Density Residential land near Jordan Lake (see Growth Plan Map) and west of the area marked as "most suitable for TND" (see Figure 6.9), the overall TND densities should not exceed Low Density Residential densities.
6.5.2 Criteria and Characteristics Common to All Residential Categories
Dwelling Types, Densities, and Lot Sizes, by Category
| Residential Category | Typical Housing Type | Lot
Size Range56 (for single family attached & detached only) |
Density Range (dwelling units/ gross acre) |
| Very Low Density | Single Family Detached | 1 acre or larger | 1 or fewer d.u./ac. |
| Low Density | Single Family Detached | 12,000 sq. ft. to 1 acre57 | 1 to 3 d.u./ac. |
| Medium Density | single
family detached, townhouses, patio homes, duplexes, triplexes |
detached:
6,000 to 12,000 sq. ft. attached: 3,000 to 6,000 sq.ft. |
3 to 8 d.u./ac. |
| High Density | townhouses, patio homes, duplexes, triplexes, apartments, condominiums | sgl. fam. attached: 1,500 to 3,000 sq.ft./dwelling | in
activity centers:58 neighborhood: 8-16 community: 12-25 regional: 16-30 other: 8 to 12 units/ac. |
| Traditional Neighborhood Development59 | all types | Varies.
Examples: detached: 4,000 - 15,000 sq. ft. attached: 2,000 to 6,000 sq. ft. |
Varies.
Examples:60 detached: 3-8 units/ac. attached: 6-12 units/ac. multifamily: 12-20 units/ac. |
Locational Criteria
Unless otherwise indicated on the Growth Plan Map, the locational guidelines for medium- and high-density residential areas are:
| Residential Category | Distance from Outer Edge of Activity Center Focus Area |
| Medium Density | 0 to 1/4
mile from neighborhood or community focus area 0 to 1/2 mile from regional focus area |
| High Density | 0 to 1/8
mile from neighborhood or community focus area 0 to 1/4 mile from regional focus area |
Siting and Layout Criteria, and other Neighborhood Uses and Elements:
6.5.3 Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND) Criteria
The criteria given in this subsection for traditional neighborhood development is in addition to the criteria specified in the previous subsection, "Criteria and Characteristics Common to All Residential Categories." Design features which distinguish traditional neighborhood development from conventional development are given in Chapter 7; this subsection focuses only on unique aspects of the types and mix of land uses in a TND.
Since a traditional neighborhood activity center is essentially a neighborhood activity center (or a community activity center, if the commercial core serves a community-sized area), the criteria given in Subsections 6.2.1 - 6.2.3 for neighborhood and community activity centers generally apply to traditional neighborhood/community activity centers as well, and are not repeated in this subsection.
Types and Mix of Land Uses
6.5.4 Low Density Cluster Development Criteria
Areas indicated on the Growth Plan Map as low-density residential may be developed in a clustered manner, in order to preserve rural and forest land. In a cluster development, a significant portion of the development remains undeveloped, preserving natural areas and providing common open space, and development occurs only on the remainder of the site. However, the total number of dwellings that could have been built, had the entire site been used for residential development, are still permitted, and the overall development density remains the same. (See Figure 6.10.)
For example, suppose a 40-acre site would accommodate 120 lots of 12,000 sq. ft. each, if developed in a conventional manner. The site, however, contains 20 acres of forest and natural areas that the developer wishes to preserve. Using clustering, those 20 acres are maintained in their natural state, and the remaining 20 acres are used to accommodate the 120 homes, by using smaller lot sizes and/or different building types.
Cluster development in areas designated for low density residential development offers several benefits: It can be used to help preserve sensitive natural areas, it enables a developer to make use of a site having significant amounts of unbuildable areas (steep slopes, floodplains, wetlands), and it can reduce the infrastructure costs for the development.
Sites developed as cluster developments should not exceed the overall density allowed under the low-density residential definition, and should generally meet the applicable design criteria that apply to that definition. In addition, the following criteria should be met:
6.6 Parks, Greenways, Conservation Corridors, and Open Space
This section defines and describes parks, greenways, conservation corridors, and open space, which are four critical elements of the Growth Plan and Map. The parks and greenways definitions (given below) and the Growth Plan Map locations for these three types of parks are taken from the draft Cary Parks and Greenways Plan, and may change as work on that plan progresses. The reader should refer to that Plan for more detailed and updated information.
6.6.1 Parks
The Growth Plan Map shows locations for three distinct categories of parks -- neighborhood, community, and metro (or regional) parks. In addition to these parks, this Growth Plan envisions other smaller public spaces which are not mapped -- such as greens, plazas, and small mini-parks -- located in activity centers, office/industrial park focus areas, and scattered about neighborhoods. These small public spaces are described in other parts of this Chapter -- principally in Sections 6.1 - 6.3 and 6.5.
Neighborhood Parks
A neighborhood park is a small park intended to serve the casual recreational needs of a neighborhood . These parks serve an average of 5,000 people within a radius typically ranging from one-half to one mile. The size of these parks normally ranges between 10 and 20 acres. Facilities within these parks can be either active or passive and are normally small in size. Typical examples include playgrounds, basketball courts, tennis courts, and picnic areas.
Community Parks
A community park is a medium-sized park intended to serve the more diverse recreational and sports needs of a community. This type of park serves approximately 20,000 people, typically within a two-mile radius. The size of the parks is usually between 25 and 100 acres. Facilities vary, but focus on large athletic fields. Larger parks may also include a community center and aquatic facilities.
Metro or Regional Parks
A metro or regional park serves the entire Town and would normally comprise an area over 100 acres. These parks should contain a wide range of facilities, with emphasis on resource-oriented activities, like boating, fishing, hiking, and picnicking.
Specialized Parks/Facilities
These facilities are normally devoted to a single use and vary in size. Examples include nature parks, golf courses, and arts centers.
6.6.2 Greenways
Greenways are linear, relatively undisturbed natural areas that meander in and around built areas within the town. Commonly, the only built improvement in a greenway is a pedestrian or bicycle path. By providing an ample amount of interconnected greenways, the town seeks to obtain a network of paths and trails throughout the town. Pedestrians and bicyclists could then use greenway paths to move between neighborhoods and commercial areas, and could also use them for hiking, biking, and jogging.
6.6.3 Conservation Corridors
Conservation corridors are also linear, undisturbed natural areas used to preserve environmentally sensitive or hazardous areas, such as floodplains, streams, and riverine natural areas. They differ from greenways in four significant ways: (1) They always correspond to natural vegetated buffers adjacent to perennial stream channels61; (2) They may be either publicly or privately owned; (3) They may include paths, trails, or bikeways; and (4) They may or may not necessarily be accessible to the public.
Outside of water supply watersheds, conservation corridors are recommended to occupy about 50 feet on either side of the stream channel. Within water supply watersheds, conservation corridors are recommended to occupy about 100 feet on either side of the stream channel.
Conservation corridors serve several purposes: (1) They provide essential protection for our water resources, acting as natural filtration areas for runoff and pollutants; and (2) They provide "wildlife corridors" which preserve habitat for many species and allow for their migration.
6.6.4 Open Space
Preserved natural areas are referred to as open space. These differ from parks in that open space generally does not have any built recreational improvements, such as trails or play areas. Open spaces are often used as buffers between incompatible land uses.
6.7 Special Opportunity Sites (SOS)
Special Opportunity Sites (SOS) are areas that present unique opportunities for development, redevelopment, and/or preservation. Special Opportunity Sites are often located around areas having historic structures or unique settings. SOS sites are subject to the base land use designation for the site as given on the Plan Map, but may present opportunities for reasonable variations in that designation, including land uses not yet considered (but consistent with the Plan). See Figure 6.11.
The SOS designation does not imply the designation of an historic district, in which historic structures are preserved in their present uses. Rather, the SOS designation signifies that these locations possess special characteristics that present opportunities for redevelopment and reuse of historic structures.
6.8 Major Employment Centers
Major Employment Centers are combinations of several plan-making elements which, taken as a whole, identify areas of very large concentrations of employment and mixed land uses. These may include significant office, commercial, and industrial employment areas, as well as supporting high- and medium-density housing areas. A major employment center is made up of one or more adjacent office/industrial parks, one or more high- or medium-density residential areas, and one or more neighborhood or community activity centers (and/or possibly one regional activity center), all in close proximity to one another. Thus, a major employment center differs from an office/industrial park in that it:
Major employment centers not only accommodate large-scale employment, but also provide ample higher-density housing in close proximity to these major employment sites. This reduces commute distances and traffic congestion, and provides opportunities for pedestrian and bicycle home-to-work trips. It also provides employers in the major employment center with a nearby labor force. Further, since the major employment center also contains one or more neighborhood or community activity centers (or possibly a regional activity center), both the workers and residents have convenient access to crucial commercial and institutional services. This helps to reduce home-to-shopping and work-to-shopping trip distances within the activity center.
Major Employment Centers serve as a concept internal to the Plan, but are not specifically denoted on the Plan Map. One identifies major employment centers on the Plan Map by examining it for the elements which comprise such a center.
Examples of major employment centers include the "Regency Park-MacGregor Park-Western Wake Hospital" area, and the "Weston PUD-SAS Campus" area. The first of these two major employment centers illustrates the concept: Regency Park contains a zoned but unbuilt neighborhood activity center and a sizable office/industrial area with significant residential support. MacGregor Park contains a neighborhood shopping center and an industrial/office area. Western Wake Hospital is an institutional land use. Also included in this Major Employment Center are the community activity centers of Waverly Place and Audubon Park and the Crescent Commons Shopping Center and its ring of related apartments called Crescent Arbors. Thus, this major employment center contains two community activity centers, two neighborhood activity centers (one as yet unbuilt), several thousand acres of office/industrial area, a hospital, several large high density residential developments, and other sizable areas of office development (Keisler Drive area) and specialized retail (Asheville Avenue).