TOWN OF CARY

REQUEST FOR REZONING/PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT

TOWN COUNCIL IMPACT STATEMENT (April 10, 2003)

02-REZ-25 Cary Park Planned Unit Development Amendment

Staff Contact:

Suzanne Prince, Senior Planner

(919) 462-3944

sprince@ci.cary.nc.us

 

PETITIONER

PROJECT CONTACT

PROPERTY OWNER

Jerry Turner & Associates

905 Jones Franklin Road

Raleigh, NC 27606

Phone: 851-7150

Fax: 851-7547

Same as Petitioner

John Larkin Smith Farm Ltd. Partners

7437 Carpenter Fire Station Road

Morrisville, NC 27560

LOCATION:

North of Carpenter Fire Station Road, west of I-540.

MAPS:

Vicinity Map - Small

Vicinity Map - Large

Zoning Map

Land Use Plan Map

Stream Buffers

Conceptual Master Plan

In Town Limits [X] Inside Cary ETJ [ ] Outside Cary ETJ [ ] Annexation Pending [ ]

 

PROPOSED SCHEDULE OF MEETINGS

TOWN COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARING:

January 23, 2003

PLANNING & ZONING BOARD:

March 17, 2003

TOWN COUNCIL:

April 10, 2003

 

 

PARCEL INFORMATION

Parcel #

Realid #

Area

0735058037 (part)

0299235

28.13 acres

0735045245

0232337

1.67 acres

 

REZONING DATA

 

CURRENT

PROPOSED

Zoning:

Residential 40

Residential 40 PUD (R40PUD) and Planned Employment Center PUD (PECPUD)

Overlay District:

Jordan Lake Overlay

No change

Land Use:

Vacant/undeveloped

This is an addition to the Cary Park PUD. These parcels, TC-3 and TC-3a (acres), will develop in conjunction with the existing TC-1 and TC-2 sites. The architecture will be compatible with TC-1 and TC-2. The additional acreage will enhance the Town Center as the main focal point of Cary Park.

  • TC-3 and TC-3 a will provide mixed-use development containing commercial, office, and high-density residential areas. Some of the buildings will have retail on the ground floor, with offices and residential condos or apartments on the upper levels.
  • There will be both surface and structured parking.
  • Buildings will relate close to the street. No interior property line boundaries will require landscape buffers.
  • The development will be pedestrian friendly.
  • Transit stops will be provided.

REZONING SUMMARY

CURRENT

PROPOSED CONDITIONS (as of 03/17/2003)

None

This is planned as part of the Cary Park Planned Unit Development. These parcels are known as TC-3 and TC-3a.

  • The total number of multi-family units proposed for TC-3 and TC-3a is 200. Residential types may include townhomes, condominiums, and apartments.
  • There will be a maximum of 200,000 square feet of commercial and 200,000 square feet of office.
  • The adopted NW Plan states that "at least half the MXD area should be used for medium to high residential development. The development will comply as follows:

50% of total floor space for the first 200000 square feet of total floor space, then 33% of total floor space above 200000 square feet or another method that would be mutually acceptable to the Town of Cary and the developer in order for the development to meet the intent of the NW Cary plan.

  • Maximum height: 5 stories.
  • Sidewalks as per Conceptual Master Plan.
  • In TC-3 and TC-3a there shall be no building setbacks, interior buffers, or streetyards.
  • There is a 30-foot streetscape adjacent to Cary Glen Boulevard and Carpenter Fire Station Road. There is a 100-foot Thoroughfare Corridor Buffer adjacent to I-540. There is a 200-foot (average width) buffer adjacent to Morris Branch. There is a 30-foot landscape strip adjacent to the outparcel along the eastern property boundary.
  • 100 unused units in Cary Park PUD can be used in any of the Town Center parcels.
  • Trees will be saved in the required buffer and open space areas. For undisturbed areas outside of the buffer and open space areas, the developer is prepared to place a conservation easement on these areas so long as passive recreational facilities are allowed. These areas will be identified at the time of site plan approval.
  • At the time of the site plan approval, the development will be arranged to orient buildings, views and access towards the Morris Branch open space corridor to the extent feasible and practical given topography and housing product type and that the specific approach will be determined during site plan approval.
  • There will be a 30-foot public greenway easement provided along Morris Branch and along the future Western Wake Expressway. Points of access between the development parcels and the multi-use paths will be provided. The specific locations will be determined at the time of sit plan approval.
  • Carpenter Fire Station Road will be a 4-lane median-divided road within a minimum 110-foot right-of-way.
  • The development will provide upgraded pedestrian crossing(s) between TC-3 and TC-1/TC-2. The specific design will be identified at the time of site plan approval. Options include specialty pavers or other materials and providing pedestrian refuge space at the median subject to DOT approval.
  • If the town pursues grade-separated crossing, then the developer will participate in the cost (comparable financially to existing condition).
 

AFFORDABLE HOUSING CONDITIONS

 

The developer agrees to work with the Town in developing an overall compliance and strategy and implementation plan that will be approved by the Planning Department within 60 days of Council action on the amendment.

  1. Applicant and/or their builders will use one or more of the following methods to comply with the affordable housing commitments made in the Cary Park PUD Plan, as amended, to assure that moderate income buyers and renters are able to obtain affordable housing:
  • Deed Restrictions
  • Covenants
  • Partnership with Affordable Housing Developer(s)
  • Partnership with Affordable Housing Nonprofit(s) or Public Agency(ies)
  • Use of Public Resources that Include Contractual Commitments to Providing Affordable Housing
  • Developer Agreement with Town of Cary
  • Non-profit Housing Organization Screening of Buyers or Renters for Income Status and Verifying Sales Price or Rents
  • Sale of Lots to Affordable Housing-focused Land Trust (none currently active in Cary)
  1. Applicant will provide a variety of housing unit types that will be affordable to moderate-income buyers or renters, including single family detached houses, townhouses, condominiums, and apartments; and that a minimum of 50% of the affordable units to be provided will be for ownership.
  2. Applicant will provide affordable units in at least four development pods (e.g., SF-11, TOC, MR-1,
  3. To disperse the lower-priced units among market-rate units.

  4. Applicant will provide written reports to Town of Cary Planning Department with each site and subdivision plan submitted to include affordable housing and then monthly after the first Certificates of Occupancy are issued in such sites or subdivisions. Build-out in the implementation schedule in the PUD refers to C.O.s.
  5. 15% of all units must be affordable as defined by the Town of Cary.
  6. Timing of affordable units:
  • at 60% of total PUD build-out, 50% of the required affordable units must be provided;
  • at 85% of total PUD build-out, 75% of the required affordable units must be provided;
  • At 90% of total PUD build-out, 100% of the required affordable units must be provided.

Moderate-income status of occupants must be assured.

 

 

 

 

REZONING HISTORY

None

SITE DATA

WATER/SEWER SERVICE

Analysis: The proposed development has adequate access to Town of Cary’s water distribution system. A sanitary sewer flow cap will apply as presented in the Data Sheet for this rezoning application. The flow cap will limit the size of the development until downstream infrastructure is available. Staff does not object this rezoning. However, staff will apply the flow cap during site plan review and approval.

This development will be required to comply with all Town of Cary utility standards and policies.

TRANSPORTATION

Traffic Impact Analysis Required: Yes [ x ] No [ ]

The Traffic Impact Analysis indicates the following road projects should be complete prior to CO.

NCDOT project – NC 55

Cary Glen Blvd – Carpenter Fire Station to Panther Creek Parkway

Panther Creek Parkway – NC 55 to Green Level to Durham Road

A traffic signal at the intersection of Cary Glen Blvd. & Panther Creek Parkway will be the responsibility of the developer subject to approval of NCDOT.

Comprehensive Transportation Plan Requirements:

Carpenter Fire Station Road: ultimate 4-lane median divided cross section with wide outside lanes to accommodate bicycles.

Analysis:

Meeting the Comprehensive Transportation Plan is an ordinance requirement. No further comment.

 

 

 

 

 

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY – CARY PARK PUD AMENDMENT – Smith Property

Wilbur Smith Associates – December 2002

 

This study has been conducted to assess the traffic impacts and evaluate the access and egress requirements for the proposed Cary Park Planned Unit Development (PUD) Amendment known as the Larkin Smith Tract. The project site is to be located in the northwestern portion of Cary, North Carolina. This report identifies the impact of traffic generated by the proposed development and evaluates it with regard to capacity, safety, and roadway requirements. The following provides a brief summary of this study’s findings.

 

 

 

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

 

The project proposal is a mixed-use development to contain residential, retail, and office uses. This project site is to be located north of Carpenter Fire Station Road, east of Cary Glen Boulevard adjacent to the future alignment of I-540. As proposed, 200 multi-family townhome/condominium units 200,000 square-feet (S.F.) of commercial retail, and 200,000 S.F. of general office space, will be constructed on-site. Under the current development plan, the project will be constructed and occupied by 2008.

 

Access for this future development will be provided via two full movement access driveways one which will directly access Carpenter Fire Station Road on the other accessing Cary Glen Boulevard.

 

It should be noted that future regional access to the project will also be provided by the planned Western Wake Expressway, which is proposed to be constructed by the NCDOT in the immediate area of the site and is planned to terminate at NC 55. When constructed and reasonable access obtained, this future Expressway would provide excellent regional access for traffic generated by this project. However, for study purposes, the Western Wake Expressway has not been assumed to be in place by the planning horizon of the project due to its construction schedule.

 

EXISTING CONDITIONS

 

Existing conditions have been gathered for the following four intersections, which make up the project study area as directed by Town of Cary staff:

 

 

This study area is located within the Northwest Transportation Zone, which requires that peak-hour volumes utilize a 90-minute average peak in accordance with the Town’s APFR Ordinance 01-012. Traffic volume data within the study area has been obtained for the weekday AM (6:30 - 9:30 AM) and PM (3:30 - 6:30 PM) peak periods. From this data, peak-hour multipliers of .966 and .947 were developed for the AM and PM peaks, respectively, and has been utilized within this report as required by the ordinance.

PROBABLE IMPACTS OF THE PROJECT

 

No-Build Traffic Volumes

 

To represent Future 2008 traffic volume conditions within the study area, the Existing traffic flow volumes were upwardly adjusted to account for normal traffic growth and any other currently approved projects within the study area.

Discussions with Town of Cary staff indicate that an annual growth rate of 5 percent per year is to be used for traffic on NC 55 and 10 percent per year for all other volumes. These growth rates were applied to the Existing peak-hour traffic volumes to estimate Future 2008 conditions without the proposed development. It should be noted that, in addition to the normal annual growth in traffic, a percentage of traffic associated with the Cary Park and Amberly PUDs has been included in the 2008 No-Build traffic volumes. Due to the design year of the project, and design years of the two background developments, 50-percent of the traffic generated by the two background developments has been included in this study.

 

 

 

Planned Roadway Improvements

 

Within the defined study area, NC 55 is programmed to be widened from its current two-lane cross-section, to a four-lane divided facility by the NCDOT. Along with the proposed widening, the signalization of the NC 55/Carpenter Fire Station Road and NC 55/Morrisville Carpenter Road intersections is expected with the addition of applicable turning lanes. This improvement is planned to be started by 2003/2004, and will extend from US 64 through the study area to I 40.

 

As part of the Amberly PUD and Cary Park PUD projects, two roadway projects are anticipated to be constructed within the study area. Panther Creek Parkway will be constructed as a two-lane facility from Green Level to Durham Road to NC 55, opposite McCrimmon Parkway. Also, Cary Park Boulevard will be extended as a two-lane facility from its current terminus at Carpenter Fire Station Road northward to intersect with the above-cited Panther Creek Parkway. With these projects, signalization is anticipated at the Green Level to Durham Road/Cary Glen Boulevard, Green Level to Durham Road/Panther Creek Parkway, Green Level to Durham Road/Carpenter Fire Station Road, and Carpenter Fire Station Road/Cary Glen Boulevard intersections with the addition of applicable turning lanes.

 

Another planned roadway project in the area is the Wake Expressway which is planned to end at NC 55 via a grade-separated interchange. South of NC 55, the Wake Expressway should, at a minimum, continue as a two-lane facility terminating at Panther Creek Parkway (proposed) via an at-grade intersection. Right-of-way acquisition for this project is expected to begin in 2006, with construction anticipated to begin in 2008 and end in 2010. For the purposes of this study, neither the Western Wake Expressway nor its extension to Panther Creek Parkway has been considered due to its expected completion date.

 

Site-Generated Traffic

 

For this project, the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation manual was utilized to estimate project trips generated by the proposed facility.

 

Based on this information, the proposed development can be expected to generate a total of 12,680 (two-way) vehicle trips on a weekday daily basis, of which a total of 558 trips (384 entering, 174 exiting) are expected during the weekday AM peak-hour. During the PM peak-hour, 1,265 trips (542 entering, 723 exiting) can be expected.

 

Traffic generated by the site will be primarily distributed to and from NC 55 and Green Level to Durham Road.

 

Traffic Volumes Increases

 

As a result of this project, traffic volume increases at the study area intersections are expected to be approximately 28 percent at the proposed Panther Creek at Cary Glen Boulevard intersection. Smaller increases are expected at the remaining study area intersections.

 

 

TRAFFIC OPERATIONS ANALYSIS

 

The Northwest Transportation Zone requires a minimum Level-of-Service standard of a D based on the 90-minute average peak.

 

Under Existing conditions, traffic operations at all study area intersections are acceptable (LOS D or better) during both the weekday AM and PM peak hours, with the exception of the Carpenter Fire Station at NC 55 intersection, which operate poorly during both time periods due to the high volume of through traffic on NC 55.

 

Under 2008 No-Build conditions, which account for annual growth, the partial build-out of both the Cary Park and Amberly PUDs, and all previously cited roadway improvements, each of the study area expected to operate acceptably (LOS D or better).

 

With the addition of project related traffic, operations are expected to deteriorate to a LOS E at the NC 55 at Carpenter Fire Station intersection, and a LOS F at the Panther Creek at Cary Glen Boulevard intersection.

 

recommended mitigation

 

The final phase of the analysis process is to identify mitigating measures, which may either minimize the impact of the project on the transportation system or tend to alleviate poor service levels not caused by the project. Measures considered necessary to mitigate roadway system deficiencies are discussed below as they relate to the impacts of the proposed project.

 

Proposed Site Access

 

As part of the proposed development plan, access to/from the proposed project will be provided via two access driveways, one along Carpenter Fire Station Road and the other along Cary Glen Boulevard. Based on the anticipated traffic volumes, the following geometrics and traffic control are suggested for each access point:

 

Carpenter Fire Station Road at Site Access

 

 

Cary Glen Boulevard at Site Access

 

 

It should be noted that as planning/development continues in this area, other site drives by future developments should be aligned wherever possible to create four-legged intersections.

 

With the above-cited geometrics and traffic control in place, the Carpenter Fire Station Road site driveway intersection is anticipated to operate at a LOS F under 2008 Build Conditions. This can be attributed to the high volume traffic anticipated on Carpenter Fire Station Road coupled with its limited roadway cross-section. This site access has the potential need for signalization and should provide for the potential of dual left-turns egressing the site if the traffic projections/buildout of the site as presented in this report become a reality.

 

The logical location for signalization would be at the "front door" of the commercial area (retail and office) of the site. At this time, specific land use locations within the site have not been identified; therefore, it would be inappropriate to specify the exact location of a signal at this time although the installation of a signal should be planned for.

 

OFF-SITE

 

Review of the intersection analyses indicates that the proposed project results in an impact at two intersections resulting in poor service levels as compared to Future 2008 No-Build Conditions.

 

Given the fact that necessary auxiliary turning lanes have already been assumed and/or provided for all locations, in order to improve the projected poor operating levels within the study area, the following roadway improvements are suggested:

 

 

 

Assuming the implementation of these improvements, operations will be dramatically improved to acceptable service levels.

Table 6

LEVEL-OF-SERVICE SUMMARY

Existing

2008 No-Build

2008 Build

Signalized Intersections1

Time Period

V/Ca

Delayb

LOSc

V/C

Delay

LOS

V/C

Delay

LOS

NC 55 at

AM

0.8

19.4

B

###

21.1

C

Carpenter Fire Station Road

PM

0.97

51.6

D

###

76.1

E

Panther Creek Parkway at

AM

-

-

-

0.70

20.5

C

0.8

21.3

C

Green Level to Durham Road

PM

-

-

-

0.72

21.8

C

###

21.8

C

Green Level to Durham Road at

AM

0.6

15.6

B

0.6

15.6

B

Carpenter Fire Station

PM

0.52

11.5

B

0.6

11.5

B

Green Level to Durham Road at

AM

0.4

10.5

B

0.4

11.0

B

Cary Glen Boulevard

PM

0.4

11.3

B

###

11.4

B

Carpenter Fire Station Road at

AM

0.6

15.9

B

0.7

17.0

B

Cary Glen Boulevard

PM

0.68

16.6

B

###

18.9

B

Unsignalized Intersections2

Delay

LOS

Delay

LOS

Delay

LOS

NC 55 at

AM

*

F

Carpenter Fire Station Road

PM

*

F

Green Level to Durham Road at

AM

###

B

Carpenter Fire Station

PM

11

B

Green Level to Durham Road at

AM

9.9

A

Cary Glen Boulevard

PM

###

B

Carpenter Fire Station Road at

AM

9.3

A

Cary Glen Boulevard

PM

8.7

A

Panther Creek Parkway at

AM

-

-

15.7

C

19.6

C

Cary Glen Boulevard

PM

-

-

23.7

C

105.1

F

a. Volume-to-Capacity ratio.

b. Delay in vehicles per second.